How to Start a Paid Newsletter on Beehiiv in 2 Hours

October 26, 2026

Beehiiv is a newsletter platform built for publishing and monetization, not email marketing in general. You can build a subscribe page and send your first issue in about two hours on the free Launch plan, which supports 2,500 subscribers.

The paid-subscription part takes longer, because Beehiiv takes a 10% cut of subscription revenue on top of your plan fee. Run that number before you commit.

What makes Beehiiv different from Substack or Mailchimp?

Substack is a newsletter business in a box with a flat 10% cut. Mailchimp is a marketing email tool with newsletters bolted on. Beehiiv sits between them: publishing tools and monetization built in, but with plan fees plus a revenue share.

Platform Free tier Revenue cut Plan fee
Beehiiv 2,500 subs 10% on paid subs $0-99/mo
Substack Unlimited 10% $0
Mailchimp 500 contacts 0% $0-20/mo

If you only ever send free issues, Beehiiv’s free plan is competitive. The math changes when you start charging.

How do I set up a Beehiiv newsletter?

  1. Create the publication. Name, URL slug, and description. The slug becomes your public address, so pick one you’ll keep for years.
  2. Choose your plan. Launch is free up to 2,500 subscribers but includes Beehiiv branding and no paid subscriptions. Grow is $39 per month and unlocks the paid tier feature.
  3. Set up the subscribe page. Beehiiv gives you a hosted page out of the box. Upload a logo, write two sentences about what readers get, and add a sample issue link. Polish matters here — this page is your entire funnel.
  4. Configure your sending domain. Add your domain’s DNS records so emails come from you@yourdomain.com rather than a Beehiiv subdomain. This takes 10 minutes and dramatically improves deliverability.
  5. Write and schedule the first issue. Use the editor’s blocks: text, image, button, poll. Keep the first one short — 400 words is plenty.
  6. Set up the welcome email. It fires on subscribe. Most people skip this. It’s the highest-open-rate email you’ll ever send.
  7. Publish and send. Test-send to yourself first.

How do paid subscriptions work on Beehiiv?

You need the Grow plan at $39 per month, plus Stripe connected. Subscribers pay you, Stripe takes roughly 2.9% plus 30 cents, and Beehiiv takes 10% of the remainder.

A 1,000-subscriber list converting at 3% at $8 per month generates $240 in gross subscriptions. After Stripe (~$10) and Beehiiv’s 10% (~$23), you keep about $207. Subtract the $39 plan fee and you’re at $168.

Now compare Substack on the same numbers: no plan fee, 10% cut, Stripe fees. You’d keep about $207. Higher, but Beehiiv’s referral program and ad network are the counterargument, and those take time to matter.

Is Beehiiv’s growth tooling worth it?

Partly. The recommendation network lets publications recommend each other to new subscribers — real value if you have peers to trade with. Boosts let you pay for subscribers from other newsletters, typically $1.50 to $3.50 per subscriber.

Both work. Both require you to already have a network or a budget. A newsletter with 40 subscribers gets nothing from these features.

What’s the honest downside?

The editor is fine, not great. Long issues with many images get sluggish. Customization on the free plan is limited — the Beehiiv badge on your subscribe page will bother anyone who cares about brand.

Exporting is possible but migration is painful. Subscriber lists export fine; your archives and analytics history don’t travel well. Treat the choice as a multi-year commitment.

And the $99 Scale tier is where the ad network and custom domains for multiple publications live — worth it only past roughly 10,000 subscribers.

Who should pick Beehiiv

Writers planning to monetize via subscriptions plus sponsorships, who want the ad network and referral tooling in one place. Publication businesses, not personal blogs.

Skip it if you only need to send updates to customers — that’s an email marketing tool. And skip it if you’re allergic to platform fees and want the simplest possible financial relationship with your readers; Substack’s flat 10% is cleaner.

Key Takeaways

  • Beehiiv’s free Launch plan covers 2,500 subscribers with no paid-subscription feature.
  • Grow is $39 per month and required for paid tiers.
  • Beehiiv takes 10% of subscription revenue on top of plan fees; Stripe takes about 2.9% + $0.30.
  • Boosts cost roughly $1.50-$3.50 per acquired subscriber.
  • Setting up a sending domain is worth 10 minutes of DNS work for deliverability.
  • The welcome email has the highest open rate of anything you’ll send.

Current plans and feature breakdowns sit on the Beehiiv tool page.

Tags: